Restaurant Menu

Our Full Restaurant Menu

/ Restaurant Menu

Pumpernickel's Restaurant

Pumpernickel's Starters

Meatball Platter: $16.99; Meatballs in Sauce with Long Hot Peppers topped with Imported Sharp Provolone Cheese served with Fresh Italian Bread

Five Cheese Stuffed Banana Peppers Platter: $14.99; Meatballs in sauce with stuffed Banana Peppers served with Fresh Italian Bread

Fried Cauliflower Served with Honey Mustard: $7.79

Mozzarella Sticks Served with Homemade Marinara Sauce: $8.49

Deep Fried Pickles Served with our Chipotle Ranch Dip: $8.49

Hush Puppies Served with Sweet Honey: $7.79

Fried Zucchini Served with Homemade Marinara Sauce: $76.79

Eggplant Fries with Marinara Sauce: $11.79; Topped with Balsamic Glaze and Shaved Sharp Provolone Cheese, served with Marinara Sauce

Cold Crisp Salads

Buffalo Chicken Salad: $13.99

Steak Caesar Salad: $13.99; Topped with grilled marinated Black Angus Steak

Greek Salad: $13.79; Topped with grilled marinated Chicken

Salad Plate: Delightfully garnished plate with fresh crisp Vegetables and Crackers Choice of Egg Salad, Chicken Salad, Tuna Salad, Ham Salad or Seafood Salad; Choices: Choice of 1 - $6.99 | Choice of 2 - $7.99 | Choice of 3 - $8.99

Fresh Beet Salad: $13.99; Mixed Greens, Fresh Beets, Feta Cheese, Red Onions, Kalamata Olives, and Glazed Walnuts served with our homemade Balsamic; Options: Add Grilled Chicken - $2.99

Side Salads - Macaroni, Potato, Coleslaw or Pasta: $3.59; All Salads made with the finest ingredients including Hellmann’s Mayonnaise

Overstuffed Sandwiches
All Sandwiches served with Chips and Pickle. All Full Sandwiches stuffed with 6 oz. of Meat

Choice of: White, Whole Wheat, Sourdough, Pumperni

Choice of :bread

(Choice of: White, Whole Wheat, Sourdough, Pumpernickel, Rye, Marble Rye, Italian, Hoagie Roll, Kaiser Roll, Onion Roll *Fresh Turkey, USDA Choice Angus, and Corned Beef cooked on the premises)

Pumpernickel’ Choice
All Sandwiches served with Coleslaw, Chips, and Pickle Add Fries or a Small Garden Salad for $1.99 Add Sweet Potato Fries or Seashore Fries for $2.99

42nd Street Reuben: $12.99; Choice of Hot Pastrami, Corned Beef or Turkey topped with melted Swiss Cheese, Sauerkraut or Coleslaw with Russian Dressing on grilled Rye

Manhattan Garden Grill: $11.99; Fresh Spinach, Cheddar Cheese, and roasted Red Peppers on grilled Sourdough Bread

Wall Street Tuna Melt: $11.99; Tuna and Swiss Cheese on grilled Rye

Times Square Philly Steak: $12.79; Thinly sliced Top Round on a grilled Hoagie Roll, covered with sautéed Onions, Peppers, Provolone Cheese, and Mushrooms

Radio City BLT: $10.99; Crispy Bacon, Lettuce, and Tomato on White Toast

The Carnegie Hall: $12.79; Hot Roast Beef and melted Cheddar Cheese on an grilled Onion Roll or Sourdough Bread served with Horseradish Sauce

The Lincoln Center: $12.79; Roast Turkey, fresh Spinach and melted Swiss Cheese on a grilled Onion Roll or Sourdough Bread with Herb Mayonnaise

The Bowery: $11.79; Fried Bologna on a grilled Kaiser Roll topped with Provolone Cheese and fried Peppers

Rockefeller Center: $12.79; Grilled Ham, Swiss Cheese, and Coleslaw on grilled Sourdough Bread

Madison Ave. Steak Sandwich: $13.79; 6 oz. Sirloin Filet topped with Provolone Cheese, sautéed Peppers, Onions, and Mushrooms on grilled Garlic Bread

Italian Hoagie: $12.79; Ham, Genoa Salami, Provolone Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayonnaise and Italian Dressing on a grilled Hoagie Roll

Macy’s Pepper & Egg: $8.99; Served on fresh Italian Bread

Italian Veggie: $11.99; Grilled fresh Eggplant, Mushrooms, Tomatoes, roasted Red Peppers, and Provolone Cheese on grilled Whole Wheat Bread

Marinated Portabella Mushroom Sandwich: $10.49; Portabella topped with fresh Spinach, roasted Red Peppers, and Provolone Cheese on grilled Sourdough Bread

Chicken Fingers: $11.99; Served with Fries

Clamwich: $12.99; Served on grilled Hoagie Roll loaded with deep fried Clams and served with Tartar Sauce

French Dip: $12.99; Thinly sliced Top Round on a grilled Hoagie Roll with Swiss Cheese, served with a side of Aujus

Pulled Pork BBQ: $12.99; Served with Seashore Fries and Coleslaw

Chicken Cutlet Sandwich: $12.99; Served with Fries

Paninis
All served with Coleslaw, Chips, and Pickle Add Fries or a Small Garden Salad for $1.99 Add Sweet Potato Fries or Seashore Fries for $2.99

Chipotle Ranch Chicken Panini: $12.99; Grilled marinated Chicken Breast topped with Cheddar Cheese, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato and our Chipotle Ranch Dressing on grilled Foccacia Bread

Chicken Cordon Bleu Panini: $12.99; Grilled or Breaded Chicken Breast, thinly sliced Baked Ham, and melted Swiss Cheese topped with Homemade Russian Dressing on grilled Foccacia Bread

Lincoln Center Panini: $12.99; Roast Turkey, fresh Spinach, and melted Swiss Cheese on grilled Foccacia Bread served with a side of Herb Mayonnaise

Chicken Pesto Panini: $12.99; Grilled marinated Chicken Breast topped with Cheddar Cheese, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato and our Homemade Pesto Dressing on grilled Foccacia Bread

Italian Panini: $12.99; Salami, Green Peppers, and Provolone Cheese on grilled Foccacia Bread

Carnegie Hall Panini: $12.99; Roast Beef and Cheddar Cheese served with Horseradish Sauce on grilled Foccacia Bread

Ham Panini: $12.99; Baked Ham, roasted Red Peppers, and Swiss Cheese topped with Spicy Brown Mustard on grilled Foccacia Bread

Reuben Panini: $13.79; Your choice of Corned Beef, Pastrami or Roast Turkey topped with Swiss Cheese and Sauerkraut or Coleslaw with Russian Dressing on grilled Foccacia Bread

Philly Steak Panini: $12.99; Thinly sliced Top Round with sautéed Onions, Peppers, Mushrooms, and Provolone Cheese on grilled Foccacia Bread

Chicken Club Panini: $12.99; Breaded Chicken Breast with Lettuce, Tomato, Bacon, and Mayonnaise all grilled on Foccacia Bread

Italian Veggie Panini: $12.99; Grilled fresh Eggplant, Mushrooms, Tomatoes, roasted Red Peppers, and Provolone Cheese on grilled Foccacia Bread

Buffalo Chicken Panini: $12.99; Breaded Chicken Breast tossed in our Wing Sauce, smothered with Bleu Cheese Dressing and topped with Lettuce and Tomato on grilled Foccacia Bread

BBQ Chicken Panini: $12.99; Breaded Chicken Breast and sautéed Onions, tossed in our BBQ Sauce topped with Cheddar Cheese on grilled Foccacia Bread

Madison Ave. Steak Panini: $13.99; 6 oz. Sirloin Filet topped with Provolone Cheese, sautéed Onions, Peppers, and Mushrooms on grilled Foccacia Bread

Chicken Parmigiana Panini: $12.99; Breaded Chicken Breast topped with our Homemade Marinara Sauce and Provolone Cheese on grilled Foccacia Bread

Wraps
All served with Coleslaw, Chips, and Pickle Add Fries or a Small Garden Salad for $1.99 Add Sweet Potato Fries or Seashore Fries for $2.99

Philly Steak Wrap: $12.79; Thinly sliced Top Round covered with sautéed Onions, Peppers, Provolone Cheese, and Mushrooms

Chicken Caesar Wrap: $11.99; Grilled or fried Chicken Tenderloins overstuffed with crisp Romaine Lettuce, Tomato, and grated Cheese

Turkey Club Wrap: $12.79; Roasted Turkey with Lettuce, Tomato, Bacon, and Mayonnaise

Steak Wrap: $12.99; Grilled Sirloin Strips overstuffed with sautéed Peppers, Onions, and Mushrooms topped with Provolone Cheese

Chicken Cordon Bleu Wrap: $11.99; Grilled or fried Chicken Tenderloins, thinly sliced baked Ham, and melted Swiss Cheese topped with Homemade Russian Dressing

Chicken Parmigiana Wrap: $11.99; Breaded Chicken Tenderloins and Marinara Sauce topped with Provolone Cheese

Italian Veggie Wrap: $11.99; Marinated and grilled fresh Eggplant, Mushrooms, Tomatoes, and roasted Red Peppers topped with Provolone Cheese

Buffalo Chicken Wrap: $12.79; Fried Chicken Tenderloins tossed in our Wing Sauce overstuffed with crisp Romaine Lettuce, Egg, Olives, and Tomatoes topped off with Bleu Cheese Dressing

Marinated Grilled Chicken Wrap: $11.99; Grilled Chicken dressed with Lettuce, Tomato, and Hellmann’s Mayonnaise

Crunchy Chicken Club Wrap: $12.79; Fried Chicken Tenderloins with sliced Tomato, fresh Lettuce, crisp Bacon, and Ranch Dressing

Greek Salad with Grilled Chicken Wrap: $12.79; Marinated grilled Chicken overstuffed with crisp Greek Salad Blend, tossed with Feta Cheese, chopped mild Onions, sliced Black Olives, Tomato, and Dressing

BBQ Chicken Wrap: $12.79; Fried Chicken and sautéed Onions tossed in our BBQ Sauce and topped with melted Cheddar Cheese

Turkey Reuben Wrap: $12.79; Grilled Roast Turkey, Swiss Cheese, and Sauerkraut or Coleslaw topped with Russian Dressing

Sandwich Extras

Homemade Soups - Made Daily

Sandwich Toppers

Fresh Ground New York Burgers
Half pound 100% Certified Angus Beef Burgers all served with Seashore Fries (Sea Salt and Black Pepper), Coleslaw, and Pickle Add a Small Garden Salad for $1.99 Add Sweet Potato Fries for $2.99 - Served with Sweet Honey

New York Burger: $11.99; Lettuce and Tomato

Cheese Burger: $12.79; Choice of American, Swiss, Provolone, Muenster or Cheddar, Lettuce, and Tomato

Bacon Cheese Burger: $12.99; Choice of Cheese, crisp Bacon, Lettuce, and Tomato

Italian Burger: $13.49; Sweet fried Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms, Provolone Cheese, and a side of Marinara Sauce on grilled Italian Bread

Swiss Patty Melt: $13.79; Grilled Rye with sautéed Onions and Swiss Cheese

Bleu Cheese Burger: $13.79; Bacon strips, melted Bleu Cheese, Lettuce, and Tomato

Pickle Burger: $13.79; Deep Fried Pickles, choice of Cheese, topped with Lettuce and Tomato

Banana Burger: $11.99; Topped with Five Cheese Stuffed Banana Pepper, Lettuce, and Tomato

Long Hot Burger: $13.99; Long Hot Peppers, imported Sharp Provolone Cheese on grilled Italian Bread served with our Marinara Sauce

Avocado Bacon Burger: $13.79; Fresh Avocado, Bacon, Cheddar Cheese, Lettuce, and Tomato served with Chipotle Ranch Dressing

Brunch Burger: $13.99; Over Easy Eggs, Bacon, and American Cheese

Pork Burger: $13.99; Pulled Pork and Onion Rings

Turkey Burger: $12.79; 7 oz. fresh ground Turkey Burger, Lettuce, Tomato, and Mayonnaise

Avocado Turkey Burger: $12.99; 7oz. fresh ground Turkey Burger, Fresh Avocado, Cheddar Cheese, Lettuce, and Tomato served with Chipotle Ranch Dressing

(** Consuming raw or under cooked meats may increase your risk of food borne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions**)

Park Ave. Chicken Sandwich Specialties
All served with Coleslaw, Chips, and Pickle Add Fries or a Small Garden Salad for $1.99 Add Sweet Potato Fries or Seashore Fries for $2.99

From The Grill
All served with Chips, and Pickle Cheeses Available: American, Swiss, Provolone, Muenster or Cheddar Grilled Sandwiches served on choice of: White, Whole Wheat, Sourdough, Pumpernickel, Rye, Marble Rye, Italian, Hoagie Roll, Kaiser Roll, Onion Roll Ad

Croissants
All served on large, fresh Croissants with Coleslaw, Chips, and Pickle Add Fries or a Small Garden Salad for $1.99 Add Sweet Potato Fries or Seashore Fries for $2.99

Triple Decker Sandwiches
All served with Coleslaw, Chips, and Pickle ~ Combinations Available Upon Request Add Fries or a Small Garden Salad for $1.99 Add Sweet Potato Fries or Seashore Fries for $2.99

Kids’ Menu (10 and under)

Our Homemade Desserts
Enjoy one of our homemade pies at your next Gathering, Holiday or Party. 48 Hours Advance Notice Needed.

Beverages

Fresh Fish
Served until 8:00 p.m. on Thursdays and 9:00 p.m. on Fridays Market Prices

Fish Sandwich: Fresh Haddock deep fried and dressed on a Kaiser Roll and served with Coleslaw and Chips

Fish Fry: Generous 10 oz. portion of fresh Haddock breaded on the premises and served with choice of Fries, Baked Potato or Rice Pilaf, and, of course, Coleslaw and a Roll

Baked Haddock: Generous 10 oz. portion of fresh Haddock baked with White Chablis Wine, Lemon, Onions, Peppers, Tomato, and Butter and served with choice of Fries, Baked Potato or Rice Pilaf and Coleslaw and a Roll

Baked Haddock Florentine: Generous 10 oz. portion of fresh Haddock baked with White Chablis Wine, Lemon, Onions, Peppers, Tomato, and Butter served over a bed of Rice and fresh sautéed Spinach served with Coleslaw and a Roll

Baked Haddock Oreganato: Generous 10 oz. portion of fresh Haddock baked with our seasoned Bread Crumbs and Wine, served with choice of Fries, Baked Potato or Rice Pilaf with Coleslaw and a Roll

Baked Haddock Oreganato Florentine - “Angelo’s Favorite!”: Generous 10 oz. portion of fresh Haddock baked with our seasoned Bread Crumbs and Wine, served over a bed of Rice Pilaf and fresh sautéed Spinach with Coleslaw and a Roll

Fisherman’s Platter: Haddock, Shrimp, Scallops, Clam Strips, and Beer Battered Onion Rings on a bed of Fries - “We dare you to finish it!”

Shrimp Platter: Fresh Large Shrimp, breaded on the premises and deep fried, served with choice of Fries, Baked Potato or Rice Pilaf and Coleslaw and a Roll

Scallop Platter: Fresh Large Scallops, breaded on the premises and deep fried, served with choice of Fries, Baked Potato or Rice Pilaf and Coleslaw and a Roll

Clam Platter: Generous portion of deep fried Clams, served with choice of Fries, Baked Potato or Rice Pilaf and Coleslaw and a Roll

Haddock Parmigiana: Generous 10 oz. portion of deep fried Haddock topped with Homemade Marinara Sauce and Mozzarella Cheese and choice of Fries, Baked Potato or Rice Pilaf with Coleslaw and a Roll

Coconut Shrimp: Served with our Homemade Orange Marmalade Dip and choice of Fries, Baked Potato or Rice Pilaf with Coleslaw and a Roll

OPENING HOURS

Restaurant Menu

Pumpernickel's Starters

Cold Crisp Salads

Overstuffed Sandwiches
All Sandwiches served with Chips and Pickle. All Full Sandwiches stuffed with 6 oz. of Meat

Pumpernickel’ Choice
All Sandwiches served with Coleslaw, Chips, and Pickle Add Fries or a Small Garden Salad for $1.99 Add Sweet Potato Fries or Seashore Fries for $2.99

Paninis
All served with Coleslaw, Chips, and Pickle Add Fries or a Small Garden Salad for $1.99 Add Sweet Potato Fries or Seashore Fries for $2.99

Wraps
All served with Coleslaw, Chips, and Pickle Add Fries or a Small Garden Salad for $1.99 Add Sweet Potato Fries or Seashore Fries for $2.99

Sandwich Extras

Homemade Soups - Made Daily

Sandwich Toppers

Fresh Ground New York Burgers
Half pound 100% Certified Angus Beef Burgers all served with Seashore Fries (Sea Salt and Black Pepper), Coleslaw, and Pickle Add a Small Garden Salad for $1.99 Add Sweet Potato Fries for $2.99 - Served with Sweet Honey

Park Ave. Chicken Sandwich Specialties
All served with Coleslaw, Chips, and Pickle Add Fries or a Small Garden Salad for $1.99 Add Sweet Potato Fries or Seashore Fries for $2.99

From The Grill
All served with Chips, and Pickle Cheeses Available: American, Swiss, Provolone, Muenster or Cheddar Grilled Sandwiches served on choice of: White, Whole Wheat, Sourdough, Pumpernickel, Rye, Marble Rye, Italian, Hoagie Roll, Kaiser Roll, Onion Roll Ad

Croissants
All served on large, fresh Croissants with Coleslaw, Chips, and Pickle Add Fries or a Small Garden Salad for $1.99 Add Sweet Potato Fries or Seashore Fries for $2.99

Triple Decker Sandwiches
All served with Coleslaw, Chips, and Pickle ~ Combinations Available Upon Request Add Fries or a Small Garden Salad for $1.99 Add Sweet Potato Fries or Seashore Fries for $2.99

Kids’ Menu (10 and under)

Our Homemade Desserts
Enjoy one of our homemade pies at your next Gathering, Holiday or Party. 48 Hours Advance Notice Needed.

Beverages

Fresh Fish
Served until 8:00 p.m. on Thursdays and 9:00 p.m. on Fridays Market Prices

Quick Links

Buy Gift Cards Online

Join our Email List

OPENING HOURS

Restaurant Menu

Pumpernickel's Starters

Cold Crisp Salads

Overstuffed SandwichesAll Sandwiches served with Chips and Pickle. All Full Sandwiches stuffed with 6 oz. of Meat

Pumpernickel’ ChoiceAll Sandwiches served with Coleslaw, Chips, and Pickle Add Fries or a Small Garden Salad for $1.99 Add Sweet Potato Fries or Seashore Fries for $2.99

PaninisAll served with Coleslaw, Chips, and Pickle Add Fries or a Small Garden Salad for $1.99 Add Sweet Potato Fries or Seashore Fries for $2.99

WrapsAll served with Coleslaw, Chips, and Pickle Add Fries or a Small Garden Salad for $1.99 Add Sweet Potato Fries or Seashore Fries for $2.99

Sandwich Extras

Homemade Soups - Made Daily

Sandwich Toppers

Fresh Ground New York BurgersHalf pound 100% Certified Angus Beef Burgers all served with Seashore Fries (Sea Salt and Black Pepper), Coleslaw, and Pickle Add a Small Garden Salad for $1.99 Add Sweet Potato Fries for $2.99 - Served with Sweet Honey

Park Ave. Chicken Sandwich SpecialtiesAll served with Coleslaw, Chips, and Pickle Add Fries or a Small Garden Salad for $1.99 Add Sweet Potato Fries or Seashore Fries for $2.99

From The GrillAll served with Chips, and Pickle Cheeses Available: American, Swiss, Provolone, Muenster or Cheddar Grilled Sandwiches served on choice of: White, Whole Wheat, Sourdough, Pumpernickel, Rye, Marble Rye, Italian, Hoagie Roll, Kaiser Roll, Onion Roll Ad

CroissantsAll served on large, fresh Croissants with Coleslaw, Chips, and Pickle Add Fries or a Small Garden Salad for $1.99 Add Sweet Potato Fries or Seashore Fries for $2.99

Triple Decker SandwichesAll served with Coleslaw, Chips, and Pickle ~ Combinations Available Upon Request Add Fries or a Small Garden Salad for $1.99 Add Sweet Potato Fries or Seashore Fries for $2.99

Kids’ Menu (10 and under)

Our Homemade DessertsEnjoy one of our homemade pies at your next Gathering, Holiday or Party. 48 Hours Advance Notice Needed.

Beverages

Fresh FishServed until 8:00 p.m. on Thursdays and 9:00 p.m. on Fridays Market Prices

Quick Links

Buy Gift Cards Online

Join our Email List

Overstuffed Sandwiches
All Sandwiches served with Chips and Pickle. All Full Sandwiches stuffed with 6 oz. of Meat

Pumpernickel’ Choice
All Sandwiches served with Coleslaw, Chips, and Pickle Add Fries or a Small Garden Salad for $1.99 Add Sweet Potato Fries or Seashore Fries for $2.99

Paninis
All served with Coleslaw, Chips, and Pickle Add Fries or a Small Garden Salad for $1.99 Add Sweet Potato Fries or Seashore Fries for $2.99

Wraps
All served with Coleslaw, Chips, and Pickle Add Fries or a Small Garden Salad for $1.99 Add Sweet Potato Fries or Seashore Fries for $2.99

Fresh Ground New York Burgers
Half pound 100% Certified Angus Beef Burgers all served with Seashore Fries (Sea Salt and Black Pepper), Coleslaw, and Pickle Add a Small Garden Salad for $1.99 Add Sweet Potato Fries for $2.99 - Served with Sweet Honey

Park Ave. Chicken Sandwich Specialties
All served with Coleslaw, Chips, and Pickle Add Fries or a Small Garden Salad for $1.99 Add Sweet Potato Fries or Seashore Fries for $2.99

From The Grill
All served with Chips, and Pickle Cheeses Available: American, Swiss, Provolone, Muenster or Cheddar Grilled Sandwiches served on choice of: White, Whole Wheat, Sourdough, Pumpernickel, Rye, Marble Rye, Italian, Hoagie Roll, Kaiser Roll, Onion Roll Ad

Croissants
All served on large, fresh Croissants with Coleslaw, Chips, and Pickle Add Fries or a Small Garden Salad for $1.99 Add Sweet Potato Fries or Seashore Fries for $2.99

Triple Decker Sandwiches
All served with Coleslaw, Chips, and Pickle ~ Combinations Available Upon Request Add Fries or a Small Garden Salad for $1.99 Add Sweet Potato Fries or Seashore Fries for $2.99

Our Homemade Desserts
Enjoy one of our homemade pies at your next Gathering, Holiday or Party. 48 Hours Advance Notice Needed.

Fresh Fish
Served until 8:00 p.m. on Thursdays and 9:00 p.m. on Fridays Market Prices